logo

Ocean Conservation News

SearchRSS Feed

For Immediate Release:
2004-06-24
For More Information:
Contact Amy Peterson
206-568-2850

Representatives Rahall and Farr Introduce First Federal Bill to Address Ocean Commissions' Recommendations: WashPIRG Supports Legislation Designed to Fix Flawed Fishery Management System

As the new home of WashPIRG's environmental work, Environment Washington can be contacted regarding this news release.

Seattle—Representative Nick Rahall (D-WV), Ranking Democrat on the U.S. House Resources Committee, Representative Sam Farr, Co-Chair of the House Oceans Caucus, and 12 Members of Congress today introduced legislation that would help eliminate long-standing financial conflicts of interest, unbalanced representation, and poor conservation decisions in the fisheries management system. This is the first piece of legislation that would enact policy proposals made by the U.S. Commission on Ocean Policy and the Pew Oceans Commission.

According to the U.S. Commission on Ocean Policy (USCOP), social, economic, and political factors have led the Fishery Management Councils (FMCs)—the bodies in charge of managing regional fisheries—to downplay the best available scientific information, resulting in overfishing and the slow recovery of overfished stocks.

"This is what happens when the fox is left to guard the henhouse. And in this case, the foxes are government-appointed," stated WashPIRG Executive Director Robert Pregulman .

Sixty percent of the appointed members of the FMCS have a direct financial stake in the fisheries they regulate. This results in short-term interests being served at the expense of the health and rebuilding of fisheries and ocean ecosystems, according to WashPIRG and the USCOP. Current law mandates that the FMCS have balanced representation from commercial and recreational fishermen, but it does not designate that the public interest be represented on these councils.

Last week, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries Service appointed new members to its eight regional FMCS, but no members from the conservation community were appointed. With this year's appointments, 58 out of 71 council positions are held by either commercial or recreational fishermen, many of whom profit from fishing-related businesses in their regions. The Pacific Fishery Management Council had one open seat. The incumbent, who represents recreational fishermen was re-appointed. Since 1986, the Pacific Council has been dominated by commercial and recreation fishermen.

The Rahall-Farr legislation amends the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, which governs federally managed ocean fish. The bill seeks to broaden participation on the fishery management councils to include members of the public, to significantly reduce financial conflicts of interest of those on the councils, and to ensure that political and economic influences do not override conservation decisions on the health of the fish populations.

As designated by the Magnuson-Stevens Act, eight regional fishery management councils manage more than 900 fish stocks in U.S. ocean waters. Council members simultaneously decide which scientific information to put into practice to conserve fish populations and how to allocate these natural resources to fishermen for economic gain. Current law mandates that these councils share a balanced representation between commercial and recreational fishermen, but it does not designate that other interests, such as the public's interest, be represented on the council.

WashPIRG lauded Representatives Rahall and Farr and their fellow cosponsors for the introduction of this landmark bill, saying: "This is just the kind of action we need to protect and conserve our precious oceans."